LogFAQs > #972490627

I totally get what you all are saying and I do agree with the conclusion (bad production), I just don't agree with the premise that the classic seasons were so much better cast-wise across the board.

As someone who only first watched this show under 2 years ago and thus have read a lot of about what the best seasons are, people really only mention the same favorite 10-15 seasons (which is a super good batting rate for a reality show, to be clear). People also mention several "dark ages" that stretched 4-6 seasons. There's no way to reconcile that with the idea that the seasons were fundamentally better pre-40. Especially since 42 was great and 41 was pretty good too. Seems like 41-44 are batting the same average, despite the worse production and game design.