LogFAQs > #972062752

So, I scanned Crescent last night and they moved. I just want to specify that my scan came back with neutral language around my target, and did not specifically say "Crescent got up" because we've been chatting about a BD/Redirector. But I have been given no indication to believe that my target changed.

I scanned Crescent because I thought that she fit well into the Death/Chris dreamteam that I had concocted, and even somewhat independently just through D1 and how she was interacting with Chris. Early D1, Chris and Crescent had a lot of kind of off-the-cuff exchanges and I kind of joked to myself in my head "what if Chris and Crescent are scumbuddies" because it felt like they were too comfortable with each other, I can't really explain it.

Then towards the end of D1 Crescent's behavior surrounding Death and Chris was quite strange.

Approx 2/3 of the way through Topic 4:
Crescent-Moon posted...

If there's something nagging me about Death it's that he's shown non-committal support to basically every train presented recently. It feels a lot more follow-y than solve-y.

Start of Topic 5:
Crescent-Moon posted...

Death's behavior of being willing to die and the vote pattern actually makes a crazy amount of sense for the Death/Chris conspiracy.

It also makes sense for both being town thinking the other is town.

I kinda think they're the same alignment here.

Crescent-Moon posted...

I want to vote Sultan more than any of these options but I kinda think Death is town now so

##Vote: Chris

I feel kinda sick right now.

The way that Crescent danced around Death/Chris was very strange. Crescent chimes in with a comment that screams "well I won't actually say whether Death is scummy or not but this gives me room to vote him if I want", then pairs Chris/Death and later calls Death town for unclear reasons. It was kind of unclear whether he was actually saying town/town or scum/scum was more or less unlikely, but that's not really the point.

The point is that Crescent tied Chris/Death together, then is convinced Death is town, and then votes Chris instead of tying the lynch on Han? If you think Death is town and Chris is the same alignment, why vote Chris? Or why not at least tie it with Han if you're so uncertain?

I have to acknowledge that Crescent's vote was really the one that put the nail in Chris' coffin but I wouldn't put it past an enterprising scum player who sees the train (and thinks to themself that Chris' role is very hard to activate) to try and take it as a chance to end up on the right side of the lynch. As well, I am very prepared to take tons of grains of salt with the whole situation given that Chris was not around for EoD when he was a role that required him to be around for EoD.

I actually think the Death flip helps my case against Crescent because it adds an element of "I knew not to go near Death EoD" which lines up with the hesistancy.

Could be wrong but those are my thoughts!