LogFAQs > #971571429

*waves from rubble of topic*

I had a feeling that one would be controversial. I can definitely see why people like it - lots of people! - but I can only give you my honest takes, and my honest take was less than favorable.

Here's another. Maybe this take is also pretty hot?

73. Marvel's What If...?
@MargaretAnnMid

For as cool a concept as alternate realities, Marvels What If...? doesnt have the most...attention-grabbing animation. I would go so far as to call it pretty plain, actually. Some of the actual art from the comics feels more dynamic than this. Its hard to really put my finger on why this is, since theres lots of action in the trailer. Maybe its that the actual characters feel stiff in some way? I dont get a sense of who anyone actually is. To be fair, with characters as iconic as this, maybe they dont feel the need to reintroduce them to us. But it left me feeling nothing. I suspect Im just the wrong audience for this show. The Marvel movies never interested me I know the characters exclusively from comics, so this trailer doesnt excite me. But shouldnt it excite me, even if I dont know the source material? Isnt that the job of visual design?

I didnt dislike anything, which is why this isnt in last place, but I was disappointed by it. Sorry!