LogFAQs > #970164753

TotallyNotMI posted...

Note to self don't read ~200 posts while lying on my son's floor putting him back to bed early in the morning you don't retain anything.

JC can you elaborate why you don't think ctes/Ben are scummates?

MZero, do you think ctes/Ben could be scummates?

I don't think ctes and Ben are scummates because if you're hunting a 3rd party together, it doesn't make sense to leave a vote on your scummate.

##unvote: ctes

I do want ctes to answer a question though. ctes, when you kept your vote on Ben you said "If Isquen is town I really doubt Ben is scum." (Topic 4 post 50, once again). But then today you said "I still think Ben looks terrible". Why the flip?

I agree with Han that plum's scumlist doesn't make any sense but I'm not sure I have the requisite knowledge to be able to appreciate exactly what a 'plum scum post' is. Generally in agreement with the pressure on him though.

On the topic of people who I feel truly haven't been scumhunting, SBell has not been impressing me today. He's been around and present and most of his actual effort has been going into BCT in extreme detail, who he thinks is 3P. He occasionally chimes in but the bulk of his chiming in has been responding to other people without adding much substantive content. I certainly haven't gotten the impression SBell has been actually scumhunting. I iso'd his entire previous topic and the only person I really got a sense of who he had any feelings about was BCT.

##vote: SBell

I think SBell tunneling BCT here supports one or both of Scare and Ben being scum (though I think them both being scum is not at all likely) and he's trying to divert attention to an alternate lynch, which makes me feel better about BCT at the very least not being scum.

With respect to the ongoing Scare/Ben/Isquen situation, I'm in agreement that Ben and Scare likely aren't scumbuddies so I have to pick one. At the moment I think I'm somewhat inclined to give Ben the benefit of the doubt overall because his D1 story fits overall with his claim, and several of his posts today have come across as particularly town. Does scum Ben go "hey this is a SUPER town BCT post" if BCT isn't his scumbuddy? I'm just also really not inclined to believe Scare's role at this point, and I don't like his explanations for why he voted.

If Ben is lynched and flips scum, I will have to re-evaluate my reads on SBell/BCT given that scum Ben promoting BCT as town makes a lot less sense, making BCT more scummy. If BCT is more scummy, it makes SBell less scummy since I doubt they'd be scumbuddies.

htaeD posted...

Okay this is what Ben claimed.
Again I can totally see Ben just doing the tea bit as a gag for no reason, but I would like Ben to explain it if he can.

Btw while I was skipping ahead in time to see this claim I caught this bit of weird logic from JC

Because I dont see how he jumps from "If Isquen not arsonist" to "Ben cannot be fireproof."

At that point I honestly didn't think that a 3P arsonist could coexist with two town daykilling roles. I was ready to come into the day thinking Ben had lied about being fireproof until the red flip.