LogFAQs > #965942688

I'm satisfied enough with DYL's posts. We got content. ##Unvote

Just one comment...

I think you're reading too into it. My interpretation of those posts were, "Between Han and Plum, Plum definitely looks worse. But I'll play devil's advocate a bit just to make sure Plum isn't actually town."
... Which Plum never addressed. So uh... that's another point against Plum. But that's just how Ben plays.

... Wait, I just remembered. Ben never confirmed me as Town! Maybe he is Scum this game, that dastard! >:(

But I mean, I am a little uneasy about Plum being too simple of an answer... but as far as Day 1 candidates go, he's probably the safest lynch. If he ends up claiming without a counter, though, I'm not sure who would be the next best option. I think I saw Red as another lynch option if Plum flips Scum? Probably just Han mentioning it, but nothing about Red has brushed me wrong so far.

Speaking of Red, though...

I... think there's a misunderstanding? My point is that:

* IGCD thinks Lea's act of claiming was anti-town because it could potentially be useful against scum (but now that they know about her role, they're obviously going to leave her alone)
* changmas argues that Lea's claim was pro-town since otherwise it would have looked bad if a townie tried to scan Lea but got blocked
* IGCD counters by saying that, because of her claim, a town power role would feel inclined to test her claim and thus waste their scan on her instead of someone else
* MZero responds that scum wasting their scan on Lea isn't as significant as multiple town power roles scanning Lea, each of them getting blocked, but unable to say anything because they don't want to reveal their power (whereas the scum team shares info with one another)
* I say that I agree with MZero and that it's not worth scanning Lea tonight when there are better options. We can suspect Lea for her claim, but I don't think there's any sense in acting on those suspicions until later in the game. If Lea has generally been town-like, then it's likely she was telling the truth. If she's been doing nothing or otherwise being anti-town, we have reason to suspect that her Invisible claim was just a hoax to avoid getting mislynched.
Let's focus on confirming other townies first, and then later in the game, if we think Lea isn't behaving like a townie, then we can invest a scan. Right now, Lea is not a high priority imo

That's the point I was trying to make here.