LogFAQs > #961061443

Just beated.

Overall I thought it was pretty good, but ShB has it beat. Part of this is because Shadowbringers got three patches of additional story that's already out, and according to the devs we shouldn't expect that for Endwalker. The other part is that Endwalker had the unfortunate task of having to tie up every outstanding major plot point in the game, resulting in some things feeling a little disjointed (hello Zenos!). Overall, Endwalker has more highs (though not the highest - Amourot is still my favorite area in either expansion), but as a cohesive unit it falls a bit short to me.

Everything else is just personal minor nitpicks. For example while I don't think the swerve into existential sci-fi elements is completely out of place in a fantasy game, unfortunately I just don't think the writers are nearly as well suited to it.