Also for the record I've never argued this. I think Chris has but whatever, Chris is an egomaniac sometimes-- it's fine.
I said scum Ulti would not be motivated enough to bus scum Chris, because if he bags scum Chris there he becomes town "confirmed" to some level and I don't feel he'd want to buckle down for the long game in a game he posted 3 times in, made a contradiction in 2/3 of those posts, and signed up as a replace in.
The only way it makes sense is if they anticipate the Scare gambit, which only makes sense if Scare is ALSO scum. Really if you think Chris is scum I think the second natural scum becomes Scare all things considered, because I only buy that interaction as a three scum super gambit to super clear a player that isn't Ulti. But like, if your scumteam has Chris and Scare in it that's probably too advanced for them to want to bother with (and also requires Ulti to deliberately put a hole in his vote post which again, seems too advanced given my likely effort level from him), so it doesn't really make sense that way either. A two scum gambit to make Scare sit pretty makes more sense, or Scare being town and honestly catching scum (in which case I, again, like Hb as scum who joined the train as he's the jump that made the least sense).
Anyway I think you're stretching too hard to lynch Chris here to the point where you're not understanding the interactions between me and him very well nor are you understanding my arguments-- probably because he's been pissing you off this game which is fair. You can better prove him wrong by just calming down and analyzing the situation rather than going super bloodlust here. Be sure Chris is scum before you lynch him. I think setup meta + day 2 end of day not really making sense with scum Chris SHOULD be enough to sell you on its own.
Chris, me, ulti would function just fine as a team and we would have no need to get that fancy at all. Chris and I have hydra'd as scum and took an impossible situation and went the distance and was only stopped at the last minute because we showed some mercy and played by our own set rules when our opponent went beyond impressively beyond them to do a huge 180 in final 3.
Like there are a lot of things I can break down in these things that just dont make sense. Even just ulti and I would function and I have no reason to skewer him to keep a town chris alive in that scenario, we gain way too much equity there. Also scum inactive ulti who is "confirmed" and on a "confirmed" igcd claim? Absolutely could cost on 3 posts a day.
I get you trying to solve, Lopen, but all angles in that situation are just dead ends