LogFAQs > #926843890

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, Database 5 ( 01.01.2019-12.31.2019 ), DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	[BOST] Best OST Contest 5 - Results and Discussion Thread
banshiryuu 09/01/19 11:15:48 PM #94:	Day 27 Results! [Sonic R - Back in Time (Instrumental)] 13-12 [Super Paper Mario - Pit of 100 Trials] [Kirby: Triple Deluxe - Mysterious Trap] 18-7 [Theresa - Vaquita 2017] [LaTale - Bard Story] 19-6 [Resident Evil 2 - Secure Place] - Future Matches: Winners Round 3: #7 Sonic R (#5 Can You Feel the Sunshine?) awaits today's results Losers Round 2: #39 Super Paper Mario (#4 Super Paper Mario (Title Screen)) vs #45 Ar tonelico: Melody of Elemia (#6 Overcoming the Trials) Losers Round 2: #50 Kirby: Triple Deluxe (#6 Soul of Sectonia) vs #5 Aurora Memoria: Philosophical Data Session 2093 (#5 SoftBank) Snubs Round 2: #3 LaTale (#6 Coal Mine (Dotnuri ver.)) awaits today's results - Also, some actual discussion I'd like to bring up here! As we approach the creation of matchups for Round 3 where songs will begin to be reused, a small realization came to me. Currently I have it so that each game represented will be using the song from songs 4, 5, or 6, that appeared earliest in the contest (i.e. the Winners Round 1 song). However, this creates a weird power dynamic where it's likely a song that has lost will play another song that has already won once. So, I'd like to ask people if they would be okay with this being changed a little bit. Here's the options I see: 1) Keep it as is. The luck factor is still there but it's easy to see what will be used. 2) Both games use the earliest winner. 3) Both games use the song that sent them to Losers. I think option 3 makes the most sense from the standpoint of being a contest for the strongest OST, since it forces a game to have all of its songs win in order to take the championship title. Either way, 2 or 3 work because to be in Losers Round 3 you have to go Win-Lose-Win or Lose-Win-Win, so the song played in Losers Round 2 can't come up immediately again anyway. There's a similar situation that occurs with the 1/2/3 songs, but the only way to avoid winning with all three of them is to lose in Winners R4/R5 and make it to Losers Finals, so I'm not that worried about it at the moment. If you have any sort or opinion, strong or not, please let me know! <cite>banshiryuu posted [p:926843890] in [BOST] Bes... [t:77915805]...</cite> <quote>Day 27 Results! [Sonic R - Back in Time (Instrumental)] 13-12 [Super Paper Mario - Pit of 100 Trials] [Kirby: Triple Deluxe - Mysterious Trap] 18-7 [Theresa - Vaquita 2017] [LaTale - Bard Story] 19-6 [Resident Evil 2 - Secure Place] - Future Matches: Winners Round 3: #7 Sonic R (#5 Can You Feel the Sunshine?) awaits today's results Losers Round 2: #39 Super Paper Mario (#4 Super Paper Mario (Title Screen)) vs #45 Ar tonelico: Melody of Elemia (#6 Overcoming the Trials) Losers Round 2: #50 Kirby: Triple Deluxe (#6 Soul of Sectonia) vs #5 Aurora Memoria: Philosophical Data Session 2093 (#5 SoftBank) Snubs Round 2: #3 LaTale (#6 Coal Mine (Dotnuri ver.)) awaits today's results - Also, some actual discussion I'd like to bring up here! As we approach the creation of matchups for Round 3 where songs will begin to be reused, a small realization came to me. Currently I have it so that each game represented will be using the song from songs 4, 5, or 6, that appeared earliest in the contest (i.e. the Winners Round 1 song). However, this creates a weird power dynamic where it's likely a song that has lost will play another song that has already won once. So, I'd like to ask people if they would be okay with this being changed a little bit. Here's the options I see: 1) Keep it as is. The luck factor is still there but it's easy to see what will be used. 2) Both games use the earliest winner. 3) Both games use the song that sent them to Losers. I think option 3 makes the most sense from the standpoint of being a contest for the strongest OST, since it forces a game to have all of its songs win in order to take the championship title. Either way, 2 or 3 work because to be in Losers Round 3 you have to go Win-Lose-Win or Lose-Win-Win, so the song played in Losers Round 2 can't come up immediately again anyway. There's a similar situation that occurs with the 1/2/3 songs, but the only way to avoid winning with all three of them is to lose in Winners R4/R5 and make it to Losers Finals, so I'm not that worried about it at the moment. If you have any sort or opinion, strong or not, please let me know!</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1