LogFAQs > #922757217

UltimaterializerX posted...

I've played 100 games and I have no clue who he is. He responded properly to multiple power players voting for him. He has earned one day if nothing else.

He was around while you weren't playing on b8. He was playing last summer. And I've seen a genuine newbie handle more pressure than this as scum and it scarred me for mafia life so I really don't buy this "too new to respond this way" thing, 5tar has the experience to know showing some fire and fighting with a big name or two is good for him, and it's not like he ever even voted Scare or Death despite calling them scum so much.

As for Scare, yeah his effort diminished as the game went on but I've gone searching through his posts so often in response to the 5tar issue and I just don't see the signs of him being scummy in there. His activity wasn't anywhere near low enough to be a case all its own.
---

Meow!