A chemical burn is way different from the burn from a fire. Plus, if the Spider-Man crawled through the vents to take the gun they wouldn't have ever been burned in the fire.
How about this, if you don't believe me, KCF can tell you what time I left my room during Night 3 to go hide in Biscuit's room with Solfadore (spoilers - I never actually left my room. I set up the vapor trap and then hid in my bathroom the entire night).
Also when I was referring to the wave machine, I was talking about more along the lines of what KP is saying:
1. If Ryoko IS the Spider-Woman (lack of a Spider-Man trophy), maybe what happened is that at the end of the last phase me and Justin were stuck in the vents and Ryoko WAS Alive at that time, but she was also hiding in the vents.
2. When Justin turned the key, the Wave Machine turned on and we rode the surfboard on the waves up through to floor 2 to look for Ryoko or her corpse. Only, instead of hiding in the changing room like you guys all thought, she was actually just hiding somewhere in the vents. The same waves that took me and Justin up to the second floor flooded the vents and crushed/drowned Ryoko during this time. Meaning there was no actual 'culprit' for Ryoko's murder, and she was alive at the time when the trial began. However, due to the wave machine crushing her, she ended up being dead by the time our votes were tallied - forcing us all to take a strike.
--
which one's green, broccoli or cauliflower?
http://i.imgur.com/XxFPf.jpg