I stand by my DVD cover - Nick, Mike, Angelina, Davie, Christian, Gabby.
People I see as returnees, in order from most to least likely - Christian, Angelina, Gabby, Davie, John (if they can make it work; Jeff said he was tough to get due to scheduling). I can only see Nick on an all winner season. I dont see him coming back for a standard all star season.
Lastly I really dont get why Jeff doesn't like this season (if that's even true... I only ever heard that like third hand). On paper it seems to have everything he would have wanted. Some strong personalities, gameplay that ran the gambit, a very Jeff-like winner, and the theme played out well.
I mean, it's possible that he was hoping his buddy, Mike, would be the winner. Especially since Mike hit a lot of the same beats as Nick. ---