LogFAQs > #913994489

Damn_Underscore posted...

Your argument is that popular music can't be the judge of whether an artist is good or not, it has to be the unpopular music. Makes so sense at all, and even less so because some bands and certain genres will automatically have an advantage over others.

Good music is good music. End of story.

Radio songs can make or break an artist for sure. But the purpose of this topic is not to say Madonna is good, it's to say Madonna is underrated. How do you convince someone to change their mind with knowledge they already know? That's all I'm saying. I never once said any of her music is good or bad, I never said she is good or bad, I never said those songs you posted are good or bad, all I'm saying is you can't expect to change someones mind with, what people interested in the music world would call, common knowledge.

The fact you have spent most of this topic defending 4 songs instead of educating me and others with a plethora of good tracks from her multi decade career leads me to believe you don't really know much more of her catalog either. And that's fine! If those 4 songs make Madonna for you then all the power to you, please enjoy. I just don't think 4 songs in 30 years, 13 studio albums is very convincing.