LogFAQs > #888239486

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, Database 2 ( 09.16.2017-02.21.2018 ), DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Anime, Manga, VN, JRPG, Related Things Discussion Topic LXXIX
YoukaiSlayer 10/11/17 2:33:35 PM #75:	FellWolf posted... Me :) Damn you bastard. There's plenty of hot non yuri girls to see get fucked. Leave my yuri out of it. FellWolf posted... What didn't you like about madoka's ending? It's honestly hard to remember at this point. Kind of funny since I wrote so much arguing about it. A lot of it had to do with not exploring the limits of wishes. For instance, why doesn't kyuubi get a girl to wish "entropy is solved". Boom. One girl gets sacrificed, universe saved, effort saved. Why? OH WAIT. I remember what my main frustration was. A writing sin that seems to only bother me. The invalidation of the journey. If the actions the main character took since the beginning were ~~pointless AND we get anything but a perfectly happy ending~~, I will be frothing at the mouth. That is also why katanagatari is on my list. Main character of madoka was ~~homura btw~~ before that causes confusion. I also felt that the show did not earn it's sad ending. The powers the main characters had at their disposal (time travel and infinite wishes) are simply too great to conceivably end up with anything but the happiest possible ending. If they had gone through the effort of creating clear and understandable limits or at least showed the characters trying these obvious things it would have been possible to end up with a ~~sad~~ ending that felt earned, but thats not what happened. Yami to boushi is on my list for basically all of the above and then some. As much as I'm angry at new game right now, I was so much more angry at that show. It does it all. ~~Invalidation of journey, ruining of yuri pairing character, twisting of yuri pairing in a unique way, memory rewrite, all of this, against the source material, and for absolutely no gain.~~. The rest of yami to boushi was so good and the ending being such an affront to humanity crushed me when I watched that. Gantz source material is as far as I know, fine. It just had a completely butchered anime original ending. The shrine maiden one was honestly probably not worth being too upset over. I'm pretty sure the show as a whole was pretty meh so a bad ending isn't really ruining too much. EDIT: Claymore should also be on my list for the same reason as gantz. --- I'm ninja (you can't see me) <cite>YoukaiSlayer posted [p:888239486] in Anime, Man... [t:75854243]...</cite> <quote><cite>FellWolf posted...</cite> <quote>Me :)</quote> Damn you bastard. There's plenty of hot non yuri girls to see get fucked. Leave my yuri out of it. <cite>FellWolf posted...</cite> <quote>What didn't you like about madoka's ending?</quote> It's honestly hard to remember at this point. Kind of funny since I wrote so much arguing about it. A lot of it had to do with not exploring the limits of wishes. For instance, why doesn't kyuubi get a girl to wish "entropy is solved". Boom. One girl gets sacrificed, universe saved, effort saved. Why? OH WAIT. I remember what my main frustration was. A writing sin that seems to only bother me. The invalidation of the journey. If the actions the main character took since the beginning were pointless AND we get anything but a perfectly happy ending, I will be frothing at the mouth. That is also why katanagatari is on my list. Main character of madoka was homura btw before that causes confusion. I also felt that the show did not earn it's sad ending. The powers the main characters had at their disposal (time travel and infinite wishes) are simply too great to conceivably end up with anything but the happiest possible ending. If they had gone through the effort of creating clear and understandable limits or at least showed the characters trying these obvious things it would have been possible to end up with a sad ending that felt earned, but thats not what happened. Yami to boushi is on my list for basically all of the above and then some. As much as I'm angry at new game right now, I was so much more angry at that show. It does it all. Invalidation of journey, ruining of yuri pairing character, twisting of yuri pairing in a unique way, memory rewrite, all of this, against the source material, and for absolutely no gain.. The rest of yami to boushi was so good and the ending being such an affront to humanity crushed me when I watched that. Gantz source material is as far as I know, fine. It just had a completely butchered anime original ending. The shrine maiden one was honestly probably not worth being too upset over. I'm pretty sure the show as a whole was pretty meh so a bad ending isn't really ruining too much. EDIT: Claymore should also be on my list for the same reason as gantz. --- I'm ninja (you can't see me)</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1