LogFAQs > #882376999

helly posted...

shadowsword87 posted...

123pizza2 posted...

PFS rules shouldn't be different from normal PF as far as crit confirms go. As suggessted by others after the first D20 roll to hit enters your critical threat range, the second D20 roll is simply used to determine if the strike does critical damage. Unless the AC of what you were fighting was so high that you couldn't hit it without a 20, it sounds like your DM was a little confused himself, which is surprising for PFS.

I have a feeling it went like this:
Player: "I rolled a crit!"
GM: "Now roll to confirm the crit"
Player: *rolls a not-20*
Player: "Dammit, I didn't crit"

It's what it sounds like

I actually don't remember the exact roll, but I was exactly wanting to say this. But it might have been a low roll. Most of my rolls are extremely low or just high enough to beat an Armor Class. Anyone who has a Path Finder Society shirt gets a re-roll. And sometimes the other players let me use a re roll and I sometimes roll lower than my first roll!
---

My FC is 4957-4763-9094 (Pokemon Sun) PS3: hellfighter45 Current: D3:UE, Xenoverse 1
PS VITA/PS4: hellfighter44 Current: Digimon Cyber , DB Xenoverse 2