Totodile: 7.5. Always liked it.
Croconaw: 6.8. It's a decent creation, I think.
Feraligatr: 9. After Swampert, best Water starter. It looks ferocious and it has a ferocious NAME that pushes the character limit. Like.
--
Owned by SuperNiceDog in the Fall 2011 Guru!
XBL: Magmortar42 | Captain America/Doctor Doom/Strider UMvC3 player. Still in the works!