LMS, the way you're using two games to compare how games should look in two different years is flawed.
- Using one of the best looking games of the year is not you set a benchmark. For example, many other games of 2005 (TP was released in 2006 though btw) probably look much much worse than either Brawl or TP. Maybe it would even be more accurate to say that Twilight Princess looked like a 2008 game!
- You're not even considering the consoles. The Wii is not that much more powerful than the Gamecube, so naturally it's not going to look that much better. Again your example includes Twilight Princess, which probably remains one of the better looking games of that entire gen. And Brawl looking that good is a compliment.
- Let's not forget the Xbox 360 was released in 2005. This elegantly combines both points before. Why did you not compare Brawl to a 360 game, which for a "2005 game" looks far better than anything the Gamecube or Wii have to offer?
--
http://i498.photobucket.com/albums/rr345/Rakaputra/pjbasis.png
SuperNiceDog - 1, pjbasis - 0