I don't mind innovating either. He's come up with some good ideas.
But sometimes I feel like he thinks he has to do something different, to the point that he can't run the same type of contest twice. And then we end up with an idea like this because he forces himself to do something different when nothing different needs to be done.
But if we get a Character Battle/Games Contest early next year, we can excuse this one the same way we do the Villains Contest and nobody will care.
--
http://img38.imageshack.us/img38/7760/222bj.jpg