I got the achievement for completing Eden Prime on August 11th, 2008, so I created the Shepherd I just completed ME2 with nearly three years ago. I've actually been playing the game continuously that entire time too, I just took a few massive breaks.
Here's my choices and results:
Mass Effect 1
- Romanced Ashley
- Kaiden died on Virmire, Wrex survived
- Council died (although I specifically chose to focus defenses on the Citadel or whatever, I didn't outright condemn them to death)
- I chose Anderson to lead the new Council
Mass Effect 2
- Romanced Miranda
- Had casual sex with Jack, attempted it with Samara, flirted and had dinner with Kelly
- Obtained everybody's loyalty
- Chose Legion to sneak through the vents and Miranda to lead the second Fire Team
- All crew members except for Dr. Chakwas died, though I'm not sure if I can prevent this
- Had Samara create a biotic barrier to protect us from the seekers while Jacob escorted Dr. Chakwas back to the Normandy. Miranda led the diversion team.
- Took Miranda and Mordin with me to the Human Reaper while everyone else stayed back to watch our back
- Chose to destroy the Reaper facility, Miranda resigned from Cerberus and I told TIM (whoa) to shut it
- All party members survived
I still have to play LotSB and Arrival, but until then I'm interested in seeing how everyone else handled their first time through the game.
--
http://img31.imageshack.us/img31/670/ohbrett.png