Melee has a bunch of easy wins that don't mean much, a loss to PW, a loss to RBY in overtime, and (if it holds on) a win against SM64. So, a loss to a lower top 10 game, essentially a tie with our #2, and a win against a top 5ish game. That averages out to a #4 ranking or something like that.
PW would have a win against a top 5 game and 2 losses against top 5/10 games, so that averages out to somewhere in the bottom of the top 10.
SMW would have a loss against a top 5ish game and a win against a top 10 game, so it lands in the bottom of the top 10.
SM64 would have a win against a top 10 game and a loss against a top 5 game, so #6 sounds reasonable.
--
90s games > 00s games