Imo, Servine should've gone before Emboar, but other than that you guys are doing a great job of eliminating the starters in my correct order.
Dewott >> Serperior > Oshawott > Snivy > Tepig > Samurott > Emboar > Servine > Pignite
(Imho)
Unsafe: 48
[0] Archen ()
[0] Archeops ()
[0] Axew ()
[0] Bisharp ()
[0] Blitzle ()
[1] Braviary (swordz)
[0] Chandelure ()
[2] Cinccino (mnk, Karo)
[0] Cobalion ()
[0] Deerling ()
[2] Dewott (Genesis, Immortal)
[0] Ducklett ()
[0] Duosion ()
[1] Durant (mnk)
[0] Emolga ()
[1] Excadrill (flubbin)
[0] Fraxure ()
[0] Frillish ()
[1] Galvantula (swordz)
[1] Golurk (Suor)
[0] Haxorus ()
[0] Hydreigon ()
[0] Joltik ()
[1] Krokorok (Genesis)
[0] Krookodile ()
[1] Lampent (GTM)
[0] Lilligant ()
[0] Lillipup ()
[1] Litwick (GTM)
[1] Minccino (Karo)
[1] Oshawott (Immortal)
[0] Pansear ()
[0] Reuniclus ()
[0] Samurott ()
[0] Sandile ()
[1] Sawsbuck (Frisby)
[2] Scolipede (Frisby, flubbin)
[1] Serperior (Suor)
[0] Servine ()
[1] Snivy (Banana)
[0] Stoutland ()
[1] Tepig (Banana)
[0] Tirtouga ()
[1] Victini (Kiba)
[0] Virizion ()
[1] Volcarona (Kiba)
[0] Zekrom ()
[0] Zoroark ()
--
Nominate Balthier/Dr. Cid for the Greatest Game Rivalry Contest! Also Tidus/Jecht, Squall/Seifer, Sora/Riku... but mostly Balthier/Dr. Cid :)