Eel or venison, probably, though I don't think either are particularly weird.
or why that "chicken" didn't really look like chicken I'd had before.
Though my sister was tricked into eating alligator this way. She cried, and cried, and wouldn't talk to my parents for days after it happened. It was funny.
--
"Oh God, maplejet's trying to be cool again. I'll call the ambulance." - Wylvane