Actually looking at his stats he's pretty impressive. I mostly made that point seeing him 49th in WAR. I just think there are better candidates. Namely, Bautista, Pedroia, Granderson, Cabrera, and Ellsbury. He's having a good season but not on the level of those guys.
But as a 1B, his WAR takes a hit.
--
(^o^) (^o^) (^o^)