Again, the problem is SIZE. Elgin is a BEAST in ROH, but take him to WWE and he's suddenly middle of the pack. He's intimidating to guys like Richards who are under 6'0" but stand him to next to Ryback and its a joke.
He would basically be to WWE what Mike Mondo is to ROH, gimmick wise.
I struggled with that quite a bit when I first started watching RoH. Seeing them hype the guy up like he's WSM Mark Henry just made me laugh since WWE has a dozen guys with more size and muscle then him.
They dont really have anyone Elgin's size right now either ,but thats more because Trips likes tone fit guys like Ziggler, so guys like Elgin have had to either get jacked or get gone.
I mean he and Cabana have similar profiles bodywise and if a guy like Colt cant make it, what chance does Elgin have?
--
~Edwardsdv~ Captain America
http://www.sethskim.com/Captain%20America%20is%20Back2.jpg