You realize she doesn't THINK she's damning the world, and legitimately THINKS she's doing good, right? Even if she's wrong, you are forcibly entering her mind and taking information that she had not agreed to give to you. It's a neutral act at best since it was done for a good cause, but is inherently kind of an evil thing to do.
The original point though, it wasn't something the entire party wanted to do and it just kind of "defaulted" that way. It happened completely in disregard of any other party member's input, even after the huge fiasco leading up to it. This sort of thing happens far too often and detracts from the enjoyment of the campaign. For me, at least.
--
Accel R8
(This space for rent)!