I'm pretty sure it'll be mainly new stuff, like Fairy Tail, Panty and Stocking, Tiger & Bunny, etc. To make Toonami successful they need to cater to a new and more modern audience... Playing the same shows on rerun would do nothing but appeal to people with nostalgia for a couple weeks until they get bored.
--
http://i47.tinypic.com/295v7ya.gif
http://raptr.com/badge/RyanSaotome/fs_lastplayed.png