LogFAQs > #961690106

COVxy posted...

When a paper gets retracted like that, it's because other scientists write responses and letters to the editor requesting retraction.

That's not how science works, though. It's not a shouting match. If scientists think that the conclusion is wrong, then they should conduct their own studies and prove it with science, not rhetoric.

You are exactly stating the reasons why Malone and others had a problem with this: this isn't science.
That's why they resigned.