LogFAQs > #960852204

hockeybub89 posted...

Women playing women's sports is not a bad idea. All biological women should play women's sports, not just most.

Would you say the Williams sisters should have gotten spanked in men's sports since their tennis dominance was unfair to other female athletes?

What is the nature of the advantage and how big is it, though?

That's the crux of the issue. Nobody argues that some athletes are better than others, or that certain physical advantages exist and are quantifiable. People only argue what the purpose of a division even is and how to define it. You don't get into the 96kgs weightlifting division if you're 103, and ruling this out is not an insult to the athlete.