LogFAQs > #953059037

My opinion of the seasons so far (spoiler free)...

Murder House: Pretty good. Had some nice twists. Went on a few tangents. Overall, good season.
Asylum: Great theme, but tried to do too much and kinda tripped over its own gimmicks. Could have been better than Murder House if not for various clusterfucks
Coven: Had some good plot points and good characters, but suffered A LOT from horrible writing and cringey campy cliche dialog, not to mention one terrible overarching plot point which I won't describe as I'm spoiler-freeing. Overall, a mess that worked occasionally but flopped most of the time imo.
Freak Show: One of the best imo. I loved the theme. I enjoyed the acting. My only complaint was out-of-period scenes. It makes no sense for characters set in the 50s to perform musical numbers with songs from the 90s >_>. If not for that, it could potentially be the best season.
Hotel: Lady Gaga was amazing in her role. I was very impressed. Never was a fan of hers until then but she really fucking impressed me. Overall story was average.
Roanoke: Interesting tone and good halfway-point shift but really it wasn't anything special. Felt gimmicky.
Cult: I loved the social/political commentary of the time. Lots of twists. Most were below average to above average in potency. I liked it more than most people did probably.
Apocalypse: I sort of liked the ties to other seasons but I sort of didn't. The throwbacks to Coven... well... I didn't like Coven. The scenery was good. The powerful new characters made the throwbacks tolerable. I was kinda rooting for the villain in the end.
1984: Started off really good but then fell into a kind of generic plot for the series even if "new" in concept. Gave me high expectations but then floundered a bit, but at least average overall.

---

I do not receive notifications, so using the @ feature will not do anything. I might see your post and respond though if I have already been in the topic.