| Topic List | Page List: 1 |
|---|---|
| Topic | Did Joel make the right choice at the end of TLOU? *spoilers* |
| Darmik 02/09/21 8:05:10 PM #60: | - Joel lied to Ellie because he didn't want their relationship to change. He admitted what he did to Tommy. It had nothing to do with him thinking it was bad. He wouldn't have done it any differently - When did Ellie give her consent to the fireflies? If my daughter said "I'd give my life to save others" in a conversation that doesn't mean an external group takes that as consent when in that situation. Not letting Ellie wake up and be aware of any sort of sacrifice is not selfless. The only person that could talk down Joel was Ellie. They were never given the chance to have that sort of closure. Nobody treated Ellie fairly. The situation itself is inherently unfair and it's handled poorly. UnfairRepresent posted... It's the act of a sociopath. Doing evil and purely selfish things for himself He did it because he didn't want to lose Ellie. How many fathers would give up their kids lives to cure COVID? Pretty easy to judge and call if evil if you aren't in that situation. This is a pretty basic moral dilemma to understand both sides for dude --- Kind Regards, Darmik ... Copied to Clipboard! |
| Topic List | Page List: 1 |