LogFAQs > #941599766

Probably directed at me.

I mean sure some fights have gimmicks but I don't think any are overwhelming to the point where you have to use a specific set-up otherwise you're screwed. Nothing in normal mode requires a specific set-up and the entire game can be beaten blind without much challenge. Hellhouse is gimmicky but can be beaten even with a bad set-up (I personally entered Hellhouse with a terrible set-up).

Having to block an enemies most powerful attack in order to not die is not a gimmick imo, that's just utilizing core gameplay mechanics.

When you get to hard mode then yes you have less leeway with what will work but by hard mode you should be a lot more knowledgeable and it's hard mode so having to be more wary on what you take into a fight should be expected. For the most part you should also know the fights by then too.

EDIT: I guess the Phantom fight that was mentioned is the main culprit of shitty design but that seems more likely to be oversight for that 1 particular fight where they didn't realize a player may enter without any way of Aerith dealing damage. You would have also known the fight was coming given it's an Aerith combat sim too.