LogFAQs > #939502019

I agree with Fastbreak/Scare here.

##Vote: Corrik

And here's why:

ViolentAbacus posted...

I do! But it's dependent on a question!

Can there be multiple people with the same roll?

Abacus's conditional answer to whether or not he had thoughts so far would imply that a specific answer to this question would confirm his thoughts. Given that the answer to the question was "yes, there can be multiple people with the same role" and then he said "All right, well then I have no thoughts!", it means that he WOULD have had a lead if roles were unique.

Thus, he would have had to be talking about the only player who had claimed a role at that point (Corrik). And (for one more step) the natural implication of that would be that Abacus is himself a TOWN Cop, which would directly prove Corrik's claim false if roles were unique. There could, of course, be more than one Cop, but I think that invites enough suspicion for me to vote up Corrik.

Please correct me if parts of this deduction are wrong, Abacus. Or provide what your thought process was when you posted that.