Pokemon will kill Night in the Woods. It lost to Edith Finch and we saw what FFXV did to it.
Bayo 1 held up to ALBW fairly well so Bayo 2 (albeit weaker) should hold up alright to Nier.
Hearthstone got 9% on OoT in 2015, in a year when OoT was a bit off and HS's reputation was probably quite a bit stronger. It'll get killed by anything the site recognises... and it probably recognises Divinity 2?
Rayman Legends lost to Diablo 3 in its polls and its brand hasn't gone anywhere good in the last half-decade. Celeste beat Dead Cells when it wasn't sharing polls with SSBU and has that "recent cool indie on the Switch" vibe going for it. (Also silly people nominated the wrong Rayman! Origins was a way better game, although I still think it would lose here.)
---
We are living our lives Abound with so much information