LogFAQs > #936160120

Try_Another___ posted...

i would be inclined to pick Sunny Day as my favorite too if it werent for the fact that they basically only have one killer album. I could never get into any of their later albums but Diary.. Diary is a masterpiece

Agreed about Diary being a masterpiece. I listened to that album pretty much every day for a couple of years as a teenager.

I disagree about the other albums though. The Pink Album has the same general feel of the Diary period & some great songs-- Rodeo Jones is one of their absolute best.

How It Feels To Be Something On does have a different sort of atmosphere, but the songs are really strong. The Rising Tide has a few stand outs but is definitely the weakest.

However, all of them feature Jeremy Enigk's great voice & William Goldsmith's awesome drumming, both of which are enough for me to listen to pretty much anything.