LogFAQs > #932081451

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, Database 5 ( 01.01.2019-12.31.2019 ), DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Now that ROS is out, which Star Wars trilogy was better?
XXmiznatorXX 12/26/19 2:19:07 PM #34:	Zero_Destroyer posted... Can you explain this? I voted the PT and I wouldn't mind having an actual debate or something. I recognize the PT has issues with its scripting/direction but there is a consistent core to what it's trying to do & say that I think works well in spite of the issues, and it ends strongly enough that I'm willing to forgive or ar least kind of excuse problems I had with AotC/TPM. I think the ST manages to fix the direction, bit script quality still varies (it is PT-tier in RoS, though) and it has no actual cohesion between the three titles. I don't even blame RJ for this because there were plenty of ideas for RoS that don't involve bringing Palpatine back. This. I think Episode 1 was lame but the last two got progressively better. ROTS has me hyped and is legit a good movie, its up there with Empire for me because of its darker tone. Even with Episode 1, it at least gives some background info on the cockiness of the Jedi and how elite and stoic they were. I can forgive the bad CGI for the first 2. They are 20 year old movies at this point. <cite>XXmiznatorXX posted [p:932081451] in Now that R... [t:78283321]...</cite> <quote>Zero_Destroyer posted... </cite> <quote>Can you explain this? I voted the PT and I wouldn't mind having an actual debate or something. I recognize the PT has issues with its scripting/direction but there is a consistent core to what it's trying to do & say that I think works well in spite of the issues, and it ends strongly enough that I'm willing to forgive or ar least kind of excuse problems I had with AotC/TPM. I think the ST manages to fix the direction, bit script quality still varies (it is PT-tier in RoS, though) and it has no actual cohesion between the three titles. I don't even blame RJ for this because there were plenty of ideas for RoS that don't involve bringing Palpatine back.</quote>This. I think Episode 1 was lame but the last two got progressively better. ROTS has me hyped and is legit a good movie, its up there with Empire for me because of its darker tone. Even with Episode 1, it at least gives some background info on the cockiness of the Jedi and how elite and stoic they were. I can forgive the bad CGI for the first 2. They are 20 year old movies at this point. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1