LogFAQs > #931960506

NeonOctopus posted...

. I just wish Episode 8 wasnt such a train wreck

I dont understand how anyone can think this and like 9

8 had 3 problems. Luke's death, Leia's space walk, and keeping the plan a secret. And it set up a vastly more interesting universe where the force wasnt limited to bloodlines, everyone had it and anyone could be a hero.

9 creates more contradictory logic. Rey heals kylo from the same wound qui gon dies from. She can't sense chewie for the cheap emotional yank only to later sense him on a giant ship. Like you mentioned with the sand. The emporer entire plan...he needs Rey to kill her with hate then lol jk I'll just force suck you both because you're a diade or w/e fucking word they made up. And kerri Russell and robot fixer up merchandise machine escaping the planet when it was destroyed after she gave up her way off the planet. and if you hated the casino scene because it was "pointless"...the entire mcguffin chase is pointless, but actual pointless instead of serving character growth it existed because hey people liked chasing mcmuffins in end game right?

And Bringing back the emporer, in the fucking title crawl, is more moronic than everything combined in 8.

Now I fully agree that disney deserves 100% blame. Rian and jj should never have shared the trilogy. If jj did all 3 the trilogy would ve better. While I would have preferred rian to do episode 9 to finish what he set up. Using Luke's sacrifice to be the beacon call for the rebellion instead of having lando magically gather the entire galaxy at one single time for the cheap pop rip off of on your left. Letting reys parents...and grandpa be nobodies. Letting ben be the villain without relying on the ot.

Episode 9 looked at end game and went people liked that let's just copy it by loading this with fan service without understanding why the fan service worked in endgame.

---

If you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all