LogFAQs > #925807914

Terraria Calamity - Servants of the Scourge: 5.5. I wrote about this song often in VGMC, so I don't really feel like treading the same ground. I'll just say the intro is at least 8/10, but then the individual parts aren't nearly as compelling to me. This is actually half a point lower than I rated it during VGMC; chalk it up to song fatigue.
vs.
Zakuzaku Actors - the witch under a blue sky: 5.5. Hey it's Mozell hey it's bagpipes. Honestly some of these bagpipe notes are too shrill for me. But then the rest of the song is very lovely. Kind of torn on this one. At least it's interesting.

and

Atelier Rorona: The Alchemist of Arland - Silent Undersea Ruins: 6. Speaking of shrill instruments, ouch that flute. This does some kind of neat things but never really hooks me; I wish it stayed in the pseudo-ambient style after the flute solo at the start.
vs.
VA-11 HALL-A: Cyberpunk Bartender Action - A New Frontier: 4.5. I've listened to music from this game several times over the last few years and I can't recall a single thing about any of it.

and

Hypnospace Outlaw - Millenium Anthem (2000 New Years Eve): 6. Quirky song from a quirky soundtrack. IIRC this was one of my least favorite tracks from this setlist, but it's still fine. Gets a little repetitive near the end. Tail ending bumps it up a little.
vs.
Final Fantasy II (PS1) - Imperial Army Theme: 5.5. Pretty uneventful march-type song.

Votes:
the witch under a blue sky
Silent Undersea Ruins
Millenium Anthem (2000 New Years Eve)