LogFAQs > #921941104

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, Database 5 ( 01.01.2019-12.31.2019 ), DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Game of Thrones Season 8: Topic 5
Nanahara715 05/15/19 5:46:49 PM #241:	HanOfTheNekos posted... Nanahara715 posted... SeabassDebeste posted... ned doesn't grant a trial to the night's watch deserter in literally episode 1 and he's literally the standard of morality in the show's universe. robb doesn't grant a trial to lord karstark and it's tragic only because it's a shit political move to him. the tarlys are executed for treason, which they are literally in the process of committing when dany executes them. Literally what. Dany is not in any position of lordship over them. Them not kneeling could be any number of things but it sure as shit can't be called treason. Will literally pleads guilty to desertion of the NW which he knows carries a penalty of death. Karstark is a vassal to Robb (not a POW or conquered individual) and admits his crimes. Tarlys are vassals of the Tyrells, who swore service to Dany. Except the Tyrells are dead by that point, I'd argue there's a higher oath to uphold to the crown, and Dany doesn't know this anyways because she didn't know who Randyl Tarly even was, so it's immaterial to her motives anyways. PerfectChaosZ posted... Aegon the Conquerer burned Harren the Black and every member of his entire family in their castle for treason before the seven kingdoms were even formed. I mean, he can call it "Treason" in the same way I can call a cat a hole in the ground <cite>Nanahara715 posted [p:921941104] in Game of Th... [t:77712103]...</cite> <quote><cite>HanOfTheNekos posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Nanahara715 posted...</cite> <quote><cite>SeabassDebeste posted...</cite> <quote>ned doesn't grant a trial to the night's watch deserter in literally episode 1 and he's literally the standard of morality in the show's universe. robb doesn't grant a trial to lord karstark and it's tragic only because it's a shit political move to him. the tarlys are executed for treason, which they are literally in the process of committing when dany executes them.</quote> Literally what. Dany is not in any position of lordship over them. Them not kneeling could be any number of things but it sure as shit can't be called treason. Will literally pleads guilty to desertion of the NW which he knows carries a penalty of death. Karstark is a vassal to Robb (not a POW or conquered individual) and admits his crimes.</quote> Tarlys are vassals of the Tyrells, who swore service to Dany.</quote> Except the Tyrells are dead by that point, I'd argue there's a higher oath to uphold to the crown, and Dany doesn't know this anyways because she didn't know who Randyl Tarly even was, so it's immaterial to her motives anyways. <cite>PerfectChaosZ posted...</cite> <quote>Aegon the Conquerer burned Harren the Black and every member of his entire family in their castle for treason before the seven kingdoms were even formed.</quote> I mean, he can call it "Treason" in the same way I can call a cat a hole in the ground</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1