LogFAQs > #905648517

cjsdowg posted...

Thanks for your long reply.

I don't understand how anyone can think Holdo is right. If Holdo said We have plan but we must keep it need to know. That would be one thing. Half the ship even people on the Bridge Crew had no clue that plan exist at all.

Next Rose literally stops Finn for being the hero that her sister was and she does nothing put people lives in danger. I just don't get it.

Thanks for tell me why you like it, I just don't get it. But you seem to be happy and not taking a piss out of the people who didn't like so. So I thank you for that.

I think the Holdo part could have 100% been done better, and so could the casino planet part. Holdo just not including Poe could have been done better, but I liked that Poe needed to learn that being a hot-headed Han-Solo type isn't actually the best idea

I feel like the casino planet was needed, because it made the scuffle between the rebels and the first order seem like an actual large-scale war instead of like, two gangs fighting over a block. It definitely could have been done better, but They needed to also go somewhere else.

I liked Rose stopping Finn from trying to be the hero because of all "You're a hero by saving the people you love, not killing the people you hate" and I really liked that. I also think if Finn died there it would've been lame, as the past two movies have turning Finn from some Coward who wants to hide from the first order to a full-fledged rebel, and if he kills himself in the first moment he really has to prove it, he was still a pretty bad rebel IMO.