LogFAQs > #903435043

ShatteredElysium posted...

Other pet peeve is towns penchant for mass claiming and doing it early. Most of the time it benefits scum way more than town. Not always but it's usually the case.

From the scum perspective, I don't think there was a single town claim in the last game which helped town more than it helped scum, based on timing.

MI's is definitely the best. Could have just hard signaled chris was scum, but overall not a bad choice to keep town on track there.

Nana's was second best, but it didn't really help anything.

Shad maybe had some justification since he had scans to reveal, and you never know what scum might already know (like we might have scanned him and known something about him) but his information didn't really confirm anything. And Han was pretty screwed just by the whole block + flipped extra kill from a scum who was known blocked night 1 logic. Shad didn't need to reveal the roleblock was a lie and scare definitely didn't need to claim. Ironically scare's claim is what got him killed.

Scum was way behind in terms of power and then town just laid all their cards face up on the table. Yes there was some upside to it, but if town just doesn't do that scum has like 0 chance of getting back into the game, period.