LogFAQs > #897110769

hard to say, but Logan has more "emotional impact" and better more relatable characters

TDK is extremely well crafted (more or less), but without the emotional connection I give the vote to Logan

I used to have a rating scheme, where basically anything artistic has three possible areas in which it could excel. can't remember exactly, but something like sensual, cerebral, and emotional. something can be beautiful (visually or audially) without being especially deep, or it could be deep without being particularly visually or emotionally interesting, or it could just be emotional, OR it could excel at more than one.

good works of art tend to excel in just one of the three categories, but great works of art tend to excel at more than one. (Dark Souls is both strongly sensual and cerebral for example, but maybe not very emotional.)

so with that in mind, (and this is of course debatable) TDK is particularly cerebral with only a little sensual and emotional, and Logan is particularly emotional with only a little sensual and cerebral.

I guess emotional wins for me these days over cerebral, since it makes for a more connective experience.
---

The truth basks in scrutiny.
http://i.imgur.com/GMouTGs.jpg http://projecteuler.net/profile/Sahuagin.png