LogFAQs > #891850819

That "what have we done" tweet from Jeff makes me believe more that PUBG could be the number one game since it bucked the no early access trend and is (supposedly since I haven't played it) buggy as hell but still made enough of an impression to reach GotY status. Or the top 5 conversation was just simply exhaustingly bonkers.

I'll take a Top 10 list stab here:

1. PUBG
2. Super Mario Odyssey
3. Nier
4. Cuphead
5. Breath of the Wild
6. Destiny 2
7. Night in the Woods
8. Wolfenstein II
9. Dream Daddy
10. Nioh

Fringe candidates are Assassin's Creed: Origins, Injustice 2, Hellblade, and most notably Horizon Zero Dawn which starts top 10 and then gets sacrificed.

Jason gets his representative on the list with Nioh

Abby makes a play for Dream Daddy with the support of Vinny

Wolfenstein starts higher on the list but as conversation is had, they drop it for underwhelming gameplay reasons

Night in the Woods is the beneficiary of Wolfenstein's fall with support from Alex and I think somebody else has played it too

Destiny 2 is in danger of not being on the list due to the vicious fall off but Brad and Dan support it enough to land it above the fringe

Each game in the Top 5 is talked about as number one at some point or another.

Breath of the Wild lands at 5 because of Nintendo and Dan SFF factor and Jeff fell off it HARD.

Cuphead is the wildcard. Everyone enjoys it but have games they want to raise up more.

Nier is the source of all angst in the Top 5 conversation proceedings as Alex leads an assault on #1 anchored by Ben.

Dan is more stubborn than he's every been and refuses to let Mario drop below Nier but ultimately concedes to PUBG since he loves it as well

It takes awhile, but everyone comes to terms with allowing a mostly early access game with glaring flaws but a powerful premise and much promise win GOTY.
---

snowpork
Zazi is OP.