LogFAQs > #975997930

Respectfully disagree. I prefer P5s dungeon designs, OST, and story far more than P4s.

As for characters, I kinda lean a little towards 5s cast more because I like Joker way more than Yu and there are a couple characters in 5 that I really like over 4s cast as a whole (Akechi, Ryuji, Futaba, Yusuke, Sojiro and Kawakami if were including non playable characters, and again Joker); but P4s cast was still enjoyable nonetheless. Kanji was awesome. So was Dojima and Nanako.

Edit: I wanted to add that I love both games P4 will always hold a special place for being the first Persona game I ever finished.