LogFAQs > #968236900

Great but I liked the previous 3D Mario more. I think there's a bit of an inherent problem with open-worldness compared to more linear levels. The open worldedness gives an amazing wow factor and a greater sense of exploration on the first playthrough but it makes the overall level less memorable and becomes a slog on repeat playthroughs. Whereas linear levels that focus on making each individual level have an interesting aspect about it is more memorable to me and more enjoyable on repeat playthroughs.

Hat in Time was a great example of that as well. Short and sweet levels that left a lasting impression and still fun to romp in again on repeat playthroughs.