LogFAQs > #967830117

Ludwig_Von_2 posted...

If you picked Ocarina of Time its because of nostalgia. Twilight Princess and Breath of the Wild are both similar yet superior in just about every way.

I personally picked OoT because I feel like it's the most consistent throughout the game. It does have it's low points (like Jabu Jabu, Water Temple, and saving the carpenters at Gerudo Valley), but those low points don't annoy me to the same level as the low points in other games

Like as much as I like BoTW, it has several things dragging it down for me. The weapon durability mechanic with no way to repair them makes exploring only to find a weapon feel not all that rewarding since said weapon is just going to break 10 minutes later. It had too many easy shrines (which are fine if there was some kind of puzzle to get into them like with the darkness area/flower garden/labyrinths/etc., but most of them didn't have that), and could have done with far less combat trial shrines (or at the very least have a different enemy in each one instead of fighting the same mini Guardian nearly every time). The Divine Beasts were an interesting idea but only 1 of the 4 really made you have to think (Vah Nabooris) while the other 3 were too short + easy. And finally, it felt like there wasn't enough enemy diversity since the vast majority of the combat encounters were against different colored Bokoblins, Moblins, and Lizalfos. Still a good game imo, but those issues drag it below OoT, TP, and MM for me. BotW 2 has the potential to be my favorite though if they just fix those issues.

As for TP, I have it as an honorable mention because its low points (overly long tutorial and boring wolf sections) don't bother me that much either, but I still dislike them more than I did OoT's.