LogFAQs > #967691114

AceMos posted...

lets look at things from HER perspective

a soldier with a known history of disobeying order some one who just that day got chewed out by the suprem commander

(also wasnt he thrown int he brig i forget)

a soldier who was DEMOTED that very day for his dis obeying orders

wants you to give him information when the only plan is so specific it has no margin of error

would you tellt his soldier who for as she knows HE could be a spy (and dont try to counter this with our out of universe knowledge of the guy)

or he could fuck up the plan by grabbing a star ship and charging off for another shot at being the big hero like he so desperately wants to be

even telling him you have a plan could mess up this nigh impossible to work plan she has

If it was just Poe, it would be one thing.

It's not. The ENTIRE ship gets behind Poe. Her own bridge crew, who have been in the same room with her while she was organizing everything, gets behind Poe. Her ENTIRE crew thought they were all about to die, pointlessly, without even trying to save themselves.

Even divorced from Poe, she was a bad leader. You're commanding people in a hopeless situation; if nothing else, you need them to fucking trust you.