LogFAQs > #963453922

Eh, Chichiri was Scummy from his inability to put forward a real argument backed by logic. It was all words, no explanation. Only reason he lasted as long was from bad meta from people assuming that somebody who votes after deadline can't be Scum.

Sheep played the best of anyone this game. Tidus oozed Town, but he put his vote where it needed to be where it mattered, so credit there. And Red's fakeclaim was stellar work.

I think, ignoring roles and everything, what would have turned this into a Town victory was that, aside from Corrik, nobody on Scum earned any Townpoints. We made some bad lynches on people for being different/belligerently wrong, so there was definitely a path to victory. Scum were doing the hide thing though, and that's enough to get by, but not usually enough to pull the win.