LogFAQs > #886103932

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, Database 1 ( 03.09.2017-09.16.2017 ), DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Picard used to be my favorite, but as I get older ...
Dash_Harber 09/06/17 12:02:22 AM #18:	Duck-I-Says posted... * Provided weapons technology to a active enemy of the Federation, the Borg, abetting an attempt at genocide so that she could get home a little quicker. - If the Federation still had the Death Penalty, she should honestly be at risk of it for this crime. And if she had gotten the entire crew killed by both sides, everyone would be dead. Also, if you watch the episode again, she doesn't give them the weapon technology, just the bombs after the fact. She also stops the second it became clear it was not a defensive war. Foolish, but not treason. Duck-I-Says posted... Murder * Tuvix - already covered No. Letting Tuvix live would have been murder of two people. The whole thing was controversial and she didn't exactly get excited about it like everyone likes to pretend. Duck-I-Says posted... * Agreeing to hand over Captain Ransom to an enemy for execution IIRC, she had no choice in that. It was him or their ship. Duck-I-Says posted... * Putting an Equinox crew member in the cargo bay, tied to a chair at the mercy of an alien species that wanted to kill him. She was willing to see her gestapo tactics all the way to his death given that Chakotay had to storm in with a phaser against her orders to stop them. Remember when Picard attempted to use a child as a bio-weapon against the Borg? Or when Sisko attempted to 'salt the earth' by poisoning an entire planet just to get the Maquis to surrender? No, that's right. Because you like them. Duck-I-Says posted... * Using Admiral Janeway's future tech to get passed the borg transwarp hub defenses Again, sort of debatable on that one. Was a violation, but she actually tried to stop Admiral Janeway's plan. Janeway strongarmed her into it. Duck-I-Says posted... * Keeping the mobile emitter Would have been much more heroic if she gave it to the Kazon, right? Duck-I-Says posted... * Gave holodeck technology to the Hirogen Not against the Prime Directive. They are allowed to share technology, just not technology that is used for weapons. Also, again, her crew is top priority. It was the only way to secure peace. <cite>Dash_Harber posted [p:886103932] in Picard use... [t:75742820]...</cite> <quote><cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote>* Provided weapons technology to a active enemy of the Federation, the Borg, abetting an attempt at genocide so that she could get home a little quicker. - If the Federation still had the Death Penalty, she should honestly be at risk of it for this crime.</quote> And if she had gotten the entire crew killed by both sides, everyone would be dead. Also, if you watch the episode again, she doesn't give them the weapon technology, just the bombs after the fact. She also stops the second it became clear it was not a defensive war. Foolish, but not treason. <cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote>Murder * Tuvix - already covered</quote> No. Letting Tuvix live would have been murder of two people. The whole thing was controversial and she didn't exactly get excited about it like everyone likes to pretend. <cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote>* Agreeing to hand over Captain Ransom to an enemy for execution</quote> IIRC, she had no choice in that. It was him or their ship. <cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote> * Putting an Equinox crew member in the cargo bay, tied to a chair at the mercy of an alien species that wanted to kill him. She was willing to see her gestapo tactics all the way to his death given that Chakotay had to storm in with a phaser against her orders to stop them.</quote> Remember when Picard attempted to use a child as a bio-weapon against the Borg? Or when Sisko attempted to 'salt the earth' by poisoning an entire planet just to get the Maquis to surrender? No, that's right. Because you like them. <cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote>* Using Admiral Janeway's future tech to get passed the borg transwarp hub defenses</quote> Again, sort of debatable on that one. Was a violation, but she actually tried to stop Admiral Janeway's plan. Janeway strongarmed her into it. <cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote>* Keeping the mobile emitter</quote> Would have been much more heroic if she gave it to the Kazon, right? <cite>Duck-I-Says posted...</cite> <quote>* Gave holodeck technology to the Hirogen</quote> Not against the Prime Directive. They are allowed to share technology, just not technology that is used for weapons. Also, again, her crew is top priority. It was the only way to secure peace.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1