I've honestly never have seen the appeal of black hole sun. Good voice, good performance, good musicians.
But the song while depressing doesn't hit the bottom, the lyics are impersonal, the chorus is overdone and predictable. It's not happy its not sad, its just annoying on some level. I think it's the eq of the guitar that's so off setting, accompanied by the drudgery of the chorus and the monotany of the verses, which shares the same slow slugging.
If songs were colors it would be like a bland shit stain smear, with the colors related to green set to a hue without spectacular brocoli or grass green, but more of a dying yellow brownish leaf green.
I've tried to enjoy it, but overall as much as I have I just think it's a bad song.