MetalmindStats posted... As you wish...
Division 1
(1) Baldurs Gate 3 vs. (16) UFO 50
(8) Tales of Arise vs. (9) Stray
(5) Marvels Spider-Man 2 vs. (12) Trials of Mana
(4) Ghost of Tsushima vs. (13) Shin Megami Tensei V
(3) Animal Crossing: New Horizons vs. (14) Sea of Stars
(6) DOOM Eternal vs. (11) OMORI
(7) Astro Bot vs. (10) Hogwarts Legacy
(2) Metaphor: ReFantazio vs. (15) Tunic
Division 2
(1) Persona 5 Royal vs. (16) Sonic x Shadow Generations
(8) It Takes Two vs. (9) Fire Emblem Engage
(5) Super Mario Bros. Wonder vs. (12) Helldivers 2
(4) Resident Evil 4 vs. (13) Cult of the Lamb
(3) Metroid Dread vs. (14) Inscryption
(6) Yakuza: Like a Dragon vs. (11) Triangle Strategy
(7) Horizon Forbidden West vs. (10) Ori and the Will of the Wisps
(2) Final Fantasy VII Remake vs. (15) Animal Well
Division 3
(1) The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom vs. (16) Half-Life: Alyx
(8) Silent Hill 2 vs. (9) Cyberpunk 2077
(5) Balatro vs. (12) Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
(4) Final Fantasy XVI vs. (13) Psychonauts 2
(3) Genshin Impact vs. (14) Black Myth: Wukong
(6) Final Fantasy VII Rebirth vs. (11) Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart
(7) Vampire Survivors vs. (10) Diablo IV
(2) God of War: Ragnarok vs. (15) Hi-Fi Rush
Division 4
(1) Elden Ring vs. (16) Guilty Gear -Strive-
(8) The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom vs. (9) Stellar Blade
(5) Alan Wake II vs. (12) The Last of Us Part II
(4) Monster Hunter Rise vs. (13) Pikmin 4
(3) Hades vs. (14) Marvel Rivals
(6) Kirby and the Forgotten Land vs. (11) Pokmon Legends: Arceus
(7) Street Fighter 6 vs. (10) Resident Evil Village
(2) Xenoblade Chronicles 3 vs. (15) Armored Core VI: Fires of Rubicon
Prioritized near-guaranteed inclusions for about the top half of the bracket, and then games that could create interesting matches to comprise nearly its bottom half. Nine Sols eventually became the very last cut.
There were, I felt, a great many games I had to snub in the process - albeit mostly almost surefire fodder, admittedly. Bayonetta 3, Dead Space, Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth, NEO: The World Ends with You, and Octopath Traveler II are a few examples that I hope hint at my process for whittling down the bottom slightly-less-than-half.
Great job! Some fun matches in there. Just a few notes:
-Astro Bot should definitely be a much higher seed given that its probably going to end up as the strongest 2024 game. I think its in contention for a 1 seed honestly.
-Rebirth and Xenoblade Chronicles 3 should probably swap places as likely Remake and Rebirth are in a RDR/RDR2 situation relative to each other.
-I feel like Alan Wake II probably ends up a little higher as it will get more popular over time.
This is all just my opinion though and I think its a great job overall, well done!