LogFAQs > #981153588

Baccano is definitely a must watch that's missing here, especially giving the time frame of a lot of these.

If you want some inventive animation in the vein of Land of the Lustrous, Beastars and Trigun Stampede are from the same studio, and Girls Band Cry is a new all time fav of mine that just finished, and I think is the best looking 3D anime to date (you would have to pirate this, not licensed yet), and it fulfills both the drama and niche interest categories.

Banana Fish is good gay drama from what I've seen, but have not finished. Bang Brave Bravern is funny and explosive M/M Mecha.

GlFate UBW is an obvious pick if you liked Fate/Zero. They're still making new Monogatari. Don't watch new FLCL.